'Pope Bans Christmas' Headlines Grossly Exaggerated

  • easter mass vatican
    (Photo: Reuters/ )
    Pope Benedict XVI waves as he makes his "Urbi et Orbi" (To the city and the world) address from a balcony in St. Peter's Square in Vatican April 8, 2012.
By Stoyan Zaimov, Christian Post Reporter
November 29, 2012|12:39 pm

Pope Benedict XVI's latest book, The Infancy Narratives: Jesus of Nazareth, challenges popular beliefs about Jesus' birth, but Roman Catholic officials have squashed media headlines that seem to portray the pope as a sort of Christmas grinch.

"I think that what people need to realize here is that the pope is trying to be as historical as he can be," said Father Robert Dodaro, professor of patristics, or the study of early Church writings, at Rome's Patristic Institute.

"He wants to see the biblical narratives as history where possible but he is also trying to explain details in the narratives that cannot be historically verified," he added.

The 85-year-old pontiff argues in his book that Christ was born several years earlier than it has previously been thought, due to a miscalculated calendar. The popular nativity scene of oxen and donkeys standing above baby Jesus and Mary and Joseph in the manger may also not be entirely correct, as there were likely no animals present, according to Pope Benedict XVI.

A Reuters report points out, however, that several attention-grabbing media headlines have been trying to make it seem as if Benedict is attacking Christmas, and that following the release of the book, "Vatican officials found some headlines they were not expecting."

Some of the headlines identified by Reuters read: "Killjoy pope crushes Christmas nativity traditions," "Pope sets out to debunk Christmas myths," and even "Pope bans Christmas."

Follow us

Other headlines that can be found around the Internet include: "The pope's war on Christmas," "Explaining the Pope's Christmas debunking book," and "Pope sets out to debunk Christian myths."

All of this apparently compelled Roman Catholic social network XT3 to publish a blog titled "The pope has not banned Christmas," reassuring believers that too much is being made of the Vatican leader's attempt to address popular traditions surrounding Jesus Christ's birth.

"No one's faith should be shaken by this book," Dodaro added. "On the contrary, it should be fortified by this account. This is a believable account of the birth of Christ."

Top Stories

Freed Persecuted Christian Meriam Ibrahim All Smiles, Husband in Tears Amid Warm Welcome by Sudanese Community in New Hampshire (Photos)

Meriam Ibrahim, the Sudanese Orthodox Christian who was nearly executed for her faith, was all smiles and her husband, Daniel Wani in tears, when they and their two young children finally arrived home Thursday night — in ...

Faith-Based Groups Crucial to Overseas Aid, Experts Say

Faith-based communities are a critical part of ...

NYT Reporter: Traditional Marriage Supporters 'Unworthy of Respect,' Deserve Incivility, Marriage Is Whatever Gov't Says It Is

Civil discourse has long been regarded as a necessary component of a well-functioning democracy. But a New York Times reporter believes that value should be abandoned in relations with those who disagree with him on the issue of ...